Email campaign · A/B Test · February 2025
The Uncanny Glow-Up Sale.
Is this business' audience more responsive to savings-led or community-focused messages?
The brief
The redesigned Uncanny Owl site launched alongside a five-day promotion for its All Access Pass. The campaign followed three beats: announce the launch, explain what the bundle includes, and remind readers before the offer closed.
The test
A statistically rigorous A/B test in which the question decided the copy. Both groups received the same email body, so the only variable was the subject line.
The results
On the launch email, the community-led subject line had a 1.49 percentage-point advantage in click rate. Open rates showed no statistically significant difference, suggesting the community-led framing was more effective at getting readers to click through to the sale.
Two subject lines, one finding
- Launch email list size
- 8,042 total recipients
- 4,021 per variant
- Savings-led
- Save $400 this week — new site, big deal
- 3.71% click rate
- Community-led
- The new UncannyOwl.com is live — come take a look!
- 5.20% click rate
From the email
The Uncanny Owl site just got a glow-up.
Preview text: “Cleaner navigation, faster solutions, clearer bundles — and a sale to celebrate.”